SBTi Electricity Clarifications: Grandfathering and Deliverability
The Science Based Targets initiative has opened a 30-day comment period on four electricity clarifications to Corporate Net-Zero Standard V2.0, including grandfathering for contracts signed before 1 February 2027. Climate Decode sets out what each clarification changes and what corporates with renewable contracts should do before the window closes.
At a Glance · SBTi Electricity Clarifications
|
What is proposed FOUR CLARIFICATIONS Deliverability regions, funding across regions, grandfathering and the 15-year age exemptions.1 |
Deadline OPEN TO 4 DECEMBER A 30-day survey opened on 5 November 2026, with conclusions planned for January 2027.2 |
Grandfathering BEFORE 1 FEBRUARY 2027 Contracts fully executed before the Standard takes effect may qualify, whenever delivery begins.3 |
Because the Terms of Reference confine feedback to clarity and practical application, and because changes would take effect once the Basis for Conclusions is published in January 2027, Climate Decode considers the window to 4 December the last practical opportunity for corporates to test their own contracts against the proposed text.3
The grandfathering test turns on the date of the final required signature and not on the date delivery begins, so that a contract executed before 1 February 2027 may qualify although the plant has yet to generate, which favours buyers able to document execution without in itself justifying signing in haste while the proposals remain open.3
The deliverability interpretation is explicitly interim and will be reviewed after the GHG Protocol revision, whose consolidated consultation is slated for the second quarter of 2027, so that contracts signed meanwhile should be structured for the market-based rules to be revisited, with the right of long-term contracts to keep the interim boundaries as the main protection.43
|
1
|
Background |
The electricity criteria of the Corporate Net-Zero Standard Version 2.0 of the Science Based Targets initiative (SBTi) require companies to set activity pool boundaries for electricity by deliverability region (CNZS-C30) and to apply market instruments only where eligibility criteria are met (CNZS-C31),5 and the Standard takes effect on 1 February 2027.3 The explainer published in June 2026 stated that instruments should generally come from projects no more than 15 years old, with the exceptions to follow in guidance by the fourth quarter of 2026,6 and our analysis of the final Standard covers the wider framework.
On 5 November 2026 the initiative opened a public comment on four clarifications approved by its Technical Council, stating that no changes have yet been made and that 40% of the scope 2 queries it received, the second most common topic, relate to the questions now addressed.1
|
2
|
The Four Clarifications |
Table 1 summarises the four clarifications as set out in the Terms of Reference, version 1.0, dated 5 November 2026.3
Table 1 · The four proposed electricity clarifications. Source: SBTi, Electricity Open Comment Period Terms of Reference, v1.0, 5 November 2026.3
The deliverability interpretation is provisional, since it remains in force until a formal interpretation replaces it, the initiative plans to review it after the GHG Protocol revision, and long-term contracts signed during the interim period may keep its boundaries for the duration of the contract.3
The funding clause is meant to cover physical and financial power purchase agreements and equivalent long-term contracts used in generator financing but not spot purchases, with tax credit transfer agreements cited as an example,3 which accords with the initiative’s statement that current practice, particularly in the United States, extends beyond the original boundary.7
Climate Decode maps renewable electricity contracts against the SBTi electricity criteria, so that signature dates, grids and plant ages can be tested before the comment period closes.
Book a briefing → Subscribe to insights →|
3
|
Grandfathering of Legacy Contracts |
The legacy clause turns on the date of the final required signature, since a contract qualifies where it was fully executed and legally binding on all relevant parties before the effective date, a contract still under negotiation does not, and the start of delivery has no bearing, so that a contract signed before 1 February 2027 can qualify although generation starts afterwards.3
Where delivery had not begun, the instruments may be used only in the activity pools the contract was demonstrably intended to cover, shown by the contract or contemporaneous documents, and otherwise the deliverability provisions apply, while renewals fall outside the separate legacy option for age-limit exemptions,3 consistent with our reading of the final Standard that a renewed contract must meet the 15-year limit and the relevant region.8
The Terms of Reference refer to long-term contracts, and the sections we reviewed do not state whether annual purchases of unbundled certificates, described in our explainer on renewable energy certificates, would qualify, so that buyers relying on them should treat the point as open.
|
4
|
Fit with the GHG Protocol Scope 2 Revision |
The GHG Protocol’s proposed revisions would count energy attribute certificates under the market-based method only where they are matched to hourly consumption and to deliverable grid regions,4 and the consultation on them, which ran from 20 October 2025 to 31 January 2026,9 drew nearly 1,100 responses from 56 countries.10 Our scope 2 reporting guide describes the dual reporting framework on which the proposals build.
The Independent Standards Board has since shown majority support for two market-based methods, one with hourly matching, deliverability and incrementality and one retaining the 2015 requirements, with the transition dates and the mandatory wording still to be determined at 16 October 2026,4 while the SBTi states that its interim interpretation supports that direction of travel without pre-empting the work.1 The clarifications as reviewed do not propose changes to the hourly reporting required of pools consuming 10 GWh or more.8
Table 2 · The SBTi comment period and the GHG Protocol Scope 2 revision on one timeline. Sources: SBTi and GHG Protocol, as footnoted.
The consolidated consultation is slated for the second quarter of 2027 and final publication for the fourth quarter of 2028,4 so that the interim interpretation will operate for a considerable period before the GHG Protocol text is settled.
|
5
|
How to Respond |
Responses go through an online survey, open until 4 December 2026 according to the initiative’s participation page,2 although one trade report gives 5 December,11 so that 4 December should be treated as the deadline. Of its 24 questions, 8 to 17 cover deliverability regions, 18 to 20 funding across regions, 21 and 22 the legacy interpretation and 23 and 24 the age exemptions,3 and after analysis in December the initiative will publish a Basis for Conclusions in January 2027, with any changes taking effect immediately.1
|
6
|
What Corporates With Renewable Contracts Should Do |
For corporates holding renewable contracts, including data centre operators and manufacturers with demand across several grids, Climate Decode suggests the following working sequence before the window closes.
- Record each contract’s final signature date, signatories and delivery start date, since the legacy clause turns on the first.3
- Map each plant and consuming facility against its synchronous grid, separating fragmented systems from contracts that depend on aggregation across regions.3
- Compare each plant’s commissioning date with the 15-year limit and the 36-month window, and collect contemporaneous documents showing the pools each contract was meant to serve.3
- For procurement under negotiation, decide with legal advisers whether execution before 1 February 2027 suits the commercial case, given that the clarifications are proposals and that the initiative has said companies should not delay action.1
- Respond to the survey on points unclear for the portfolio, such as renewals, tax credit transfer structures and rolling certificate purchases.3
A company that completes the first three steps before 4 December will know from its own contract register which instruments fall within the legacy clause, which depend on the interim boundaries and which would need re-sourcing, so that its response and its procurement calendar rest on the same evidence.
Climate Decode Platform
Climate Decode tracks the standards, registries and market data behind renewable electricity claims in Market Watch, and manages certificate and contract procurement in Canopy.
Supply, demand and pricing across voluntary, CORSIA-eligible and Article 6 credits, by country, project type and methodology.
Open Market Watch →Canopy handles renewable energy certificates, energy attribute certificates and contract records in one place, and keeps an audit-ready record of every purchase.
Explore Canopy →Notes and sources
2 SBTi, Take part: Corporate Net-Zero Standard Version 2.0, Strengthening Electricity Criteria (survey open until 4 December 2026), read 15 November 2026.
3 SBTi, Electricity Open Comment Period Terms of Reference, version 1.0, 5 November 2026, sections 1 to 6.
4 GHG Protocol, Scope 2 Market-based Method Update: From 2025-2026 Public Consultation to Current Status, 16 October 2026.
5 SBTi, Corporate Net-Zero Standard Version 2.0, chapter 4 (Target implementation), criteria CNZS-C30 and CNZS-C31.
6 SBTi, Understanding Scope 2 in the Updated Corporate Net-Zero Standard V2.0, June 2026.
7 ESG Dive, SBTi looks to clarify scope 2 guidance, 9 November 2026 (trade press, used for the description of current practice in the United States).
8 Climate Decode, SBTi Net-Zero Standard V2.0 Final, 11 June 2026.
9 GHG Protocol, Public consultations now open: Scope 2 and electricity sector consequential, consultation period 20 October 2025 to 31 January 2026.
10 GHG Protocol, GHG Protocol announces key standard development updates, 29 July 2026.
11 Trellis, SBTi seeks more input on net zero electricity rules, 9 November 2026 (trade press, used only for the reported 5 December closing date).
Sources
SBTi: Take part, Strengthening Electricity Criteria survey
SBTi: Electricity Open Comment Period Terms of Reference, v1.0, 5 November 2026
GHG Protocol: Scope 2 Market-based Method Update, 16 October 2026
SBTi: Corporate Net-Zero Standard V2.0, chapter 4, Target implementation
SBTi: Understanding Scope 2 in the Updated Corporate Net-Zero Standard V2.0, June 2026
ESG Dive: SBTi looks to clarify scope 2 guidance, 9 November 2026
Climate Decode: SBTi Net-Zero Standard V2.0 Final
GHG Protocol: Public consultations now open, Scope 2 and electricity sector consequential
GHG Protocol: Key standard development updates, 29 July 2026
Trellis: SBTi seeks more input on net zero electricity rules, 9 November 2026
The clarifications are proposals open to comment; the interpretation of each criterion may change before the Basis for Conclusions is published. This article is analysis and not legal advice.
|
© 2026 Climate Decode · Market Analysis · Reference CD-VCM-SBTI-E1 |
Series Home Insights Home Contact Us |