Market Analysis · CD-VCM-UKGR
Voluntary Market · United Kingdom Claims · Benchmarks · Safe Harbour Analysis · November 2026

UK Response on Voluntary Carbon Markets: Benchmarks, Claims and the Safe Harbour Question

The UK government published on 12 November 2026 its response to the Raising Integrity consultation, endorsing three uses of carbon credits, naming CCPs and PACM as the key quality benchmarks, leaving claims to the Advertising Standards Authority and awaiting the IETA options on a safe harbour.

By Vaibhav Jain · Managing Director, Climate Decode · · 9 min read

UNITED KINGDOM · VOLUNTARY MARKETS 12 NOVEMBER 2026 CONSULTATION RESPONSES17 April to 10 July 2025200three uses of credits endorsed QUALITY BENCHMARKSPrioritised, not a minimum requirementCCP + PACMCCP premium of about 19% UK PURCHASES, FIRST HALF 2026Overseas against domestic projects£14.2m : £1.8mdomestic up 60% year on year PRACTICAL GUIDANCEFrom planning to retirement and disclosureSpring 2027Regulator Forum in the first half Benchmarks set, claims left to the ASA, safe harbour awaiting the IETA options work GUIDANCE FIRST, PROTECTION STILL TO COME

At a Glance · UK Government Response

Use of credits

THREE USES ENDORSED

Ongoing emissions responsibility under SBTi V2.0, durable removals for residual emissions and historical emissions, alongside action in the value chain.

Quality

CCP AND PACM AS BENCHMARKS

Buyers are encouraged to prioritise CCP and PACM credits where supply exists, a softer position than the minimum requirement first proposed.

Safe harbour

NO DECISION YET

IETA is developing the options through the Coalition to Grow Carbon Markets, and the government will respond to its recommendations in due course.

Our View

The government response gives UK buyers a framework that matches the direction of international practice, endorsing ongoing emissions responsibility under SBTi V2.0, durable removals for residual emissions and the addressing of historical emissions, naming CCPs and PACM as the benchmarks and leaving claims to the ASA guidance, so that a company buying credits in 2027 can explain its approach by reference to rules that its peers in Europe and in the SBTi system already recognise, and some action is better than no action provided the action is real, verifiable and robust.

UK companies bought credits worth £16.0 million in the first half of 2026 against global retirements that have been flat at 194 to 202 MtCO2e a year for four years, and the response by itself is unlikely to scale that market, since it adopts guidance, benchmarks and a possible recognition scheme while setting aside credit-use mandates and fiscal measures, so that the growth in UK demand will come from the mandatory role of credits under SBTi V2.0 from 2035, the integration of removals into the UK ETS and CORSIA under Carbon Budget 6, with the response giving buyers the clarity to act on those drivers rather than a reason of its own to buy.

The step that would change behaviour sooner is protection for the companies that follow the rules, since a benchmark buyers are encouraged to prioritise and a claims position resting on advertising guidance leave a company that follows them with the same exposure to complaint as one that does not, and companies that use high-integrity credits and make accurate contribution claims should be given that protection, through the recognition scheme proposed for the spring 2027 guidance in the first instance and a statutory defence once the evidence base allows, while UK buyers document their purchases against the three endorsed uses and the CCP and PACM benchmarks in the meantime so that they are ready to qualify when the scheme is set.

1

Consultation and Response

The Department for Energy Security and Net Zero, together with the Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs and HM Treasury, published on 12 November 2026 the government response to the consultation Voluntary Carbon and Nature Markets: Raising Integrity, which ran from 17 April to 10 July 2025 and received 200 responses from businesses, financial institutions, project developers, civil society, the public sector, standards bodies and academics, a factual summary of those responses having been published on 26 March 2026.1,2

The consultation had sought views on, among other matters, endorsing the Core Carbon Principles as a minimum quality requirement and on measures to grow demand, and the response settles the main questions on use, quality and claims while leaving the question of legal protection for companies that follow the rules to the options work commissioned through the Coalition to Grow Carbon Markets, as set out in section 5 below.1

TopicGovernment response, 12 November 2026
Use of creditsThree uses endorsed for immediate business use, as a complement to action in the value chain
Credit qualityCCPs and PACM named as the key benchmarks, which buyers are encouraged to prioritise where supply exists, in place of the proposed minimum requirement
ClaimsNo UK claims standard and no legislated definition of carbon neutrality; ASA guidance of July 2026 is the reference
Corresponding adjustmentsNot required for voluntary use where not mandatory; buyers encouraged to report whether they apply
Safe harbourOptions work commissioned through the Coalition and taken forward by IETA; no decision on statutory protection
OversightA Carbon and Nature Markets Regulator Forum, which will not regulate markets, from the first half of 2027

Table 1 · Final government position by topic. Source: DESNZ, Defra and HM Treasury, government response, 12 November 2026.

The foreword is signed by Katie White for DESNZ, Lucy Rigby for HM Treasury and Jenny Riddell-Carpenter for Defra, and the United Kingdom co-chairs the Coalition to Grow Carbon Markets with Kenya and Singapore, so that the domestic guidance and the international policy work on demand are being developed by the same government in parallel.1,3

2

Use of Credits

The response endorses three uses of credits as valuable concepts for immediate business use, being the taking of responsibility for ongoing emissions as set out in the SBTi Corporate Net-Zero Standard V2.0, the counterbalancing of residual emissions at organisational net zero with high-quality durable removals, and the addressing of historical emissions, and it states that credits should complement and not replace action in the value chain, with portfolios combining UK and international projects encouraged.1

The government welcomes the mandatory role that SBTi V2.0 gives to high-integrity credits from 2035 under the Ongoing Emissions Responsibility framework, notes analysis suggesting that this could significantly increase retirements even under conservative uptake, and asks for stronger incentives before 2035 so that compliant supply is developed sooner, which is consistent with the reading set out in our analysis of the final SBTi V2 standard.1

Global retirements have been flat at 194 to 202 MtCO2e a year for four years according to the response, and UK companies bought credits worth £1.8 million from domestic projects in the first half of 2026, an increase of 60% on the first half of 2025, against £14.2 million from projects overseas, so that domestic projects accounted for about one pound in nine of UK purchases.1

UK company purchases of carbon credits, first half of 2026
Overseas projects
£14.2m
UK projects
up 60% on the first half of 2025
£1.8m
The response describes the overseas share as 88% of the total; the two values it gives sum to £16.0 million, of which £14.2 million is about 89%.
Figure 1 · Value of carbon credits bought by UK companies in the first half of 2026, by project location. Source: DESNZ, Defra and HM Treasury, government response, 12 November 2026, section on demand.

The figures describe a market in which UK buyers already source most of their credits abroad, so that the endorsement of international portfolios in the response reflects current practice, while the Woodland Carbon Purchase Fund and the procurement measures discussed in section 6 are directed at the domestic share.1

Canopy supports insetting and residual emissions strategies with policy and peer benchmarks built in, detailed due diligence and FLAG and LSR reporting.

Talk to Our Team →
3

Quality Benchmarks

The consultation had proposed endorsing the Core Carbon Principles of the Integrity Council for the Voluntary Carbon Market as a minimum quality requirement, and the response instead names the CCPs and the ICVCM Assessment Framework, together with the Paris Agreement Crediting Mechanism, as the key benchmarks for high-integrity credits, which buyers are encouraged to prioritise where supply exists, citing a price premium of around 19% for CCP-labelled credits and more than 100 Mt of such credits approved to date.1

The Woodland Carbon Code applied for CCP endorsement in November 2025 and its assessment is under way, credit ratings are encouraged as project-level assurance although the response accepts that their cost may be prohibitive for small UK nature projects, and airlines are to use units meeting the ICAO Emissions Unit Eligibility Criteria under CORSIA.1 Our VCM Market Outlook 2026 sets out the supply, demand and price context in which these benchmarks will apply.

A benchmark that buyers are encouraged to prioritise leaves the choice with the buyer, so that a company may still retire credits outside the CCP and PACM pool and remain within the government framework, provided it reports what it has bought, while the guidance due in spring 2027 is expected to set out how that reporting should be done.1

4

Claims and Adjustments

The response does not introduce a UK-specific claims standard or legislate a definition of carbon neutrality, citing the risk of fragmentation and a preference for influencing international standards, and it points instead to the Advertising Standards Authority guidance Greenspeaking with Confidence of July 2026 on how claims such as carbon neutral or net zero should be framed, the ASA being a member of the new Regulator Forum.1

The Committee of Advertising Practice published the guidance on 30 July 2026 as an update to its guidance on misleading environmental claims, together with the practical guide Greenspeaking with Confidence and a checklist, built on five principles covering how consumers understand a claim, the evidence held for it, not overstating benefits, clarity of claims and qualifications, and transparency about targets and ambitions, and it advises advertisers to avoid unqualified carbon neutral or net zero claims, to state whether a claim rests on reductions or on offsetting and to explain the timeline behind any claim about a future target, consumer research for the ASA having found that many people read carbon neutral as an absolute reduction in emissions.4

The ASA applied the same principles in its ruling against Eurowings, finding that claims that passengers could fly more climate-consciously by offsetting their emissions gave a misleading impression because the airline could not show that the emissions of a specific flight would be fully offset, so that UK rules do not prohibit claims based on credits as the European Union now does but require any such claim to be qualified, evidenced and decided case by case.4

The Voluntary Carbon Markets Integrity Initiative is welcomed for its consultative approach, although the response records low uptake of its Claims Code and minimal uptake of its Scope 3 Action Code since April 2025 and stops short of endorsing either code, which leaves UK companies with the SBTi standard for the use of credits and the ASA guidance for how that use is communicated.1

Where corresponding adjustments are not mandatory, as they are under Article 6.2 and CORSIA, the response states that buyers acting in line with the framework need not seek them, and it encourages buyers to report whether an adjustment applies or is intended, so that a voluntary contribution claim does not depend on the host country authorising the credit.1

The approach follows the direction taken in the European Union, where offset-based product claims have been banned since 27 September 2026, as set out in our analysis of the EU ban and what credit buyers can still say, although the United Kingdom relies on advertising guidance rather than a directive to draw the line between contribution and neutrality.

5

Safe Harbour

The response defines a safe harbour as a set of government-backed protections that reduce the reputational, legal and other risks faced by organisations that follow defined rules, and it records that the government commissioned work on the options through the Coalition to Grow Carbon Markets, which the International Emissions Trading Association is taking forward and which covers both the integrity of the credit and the integrity of the claim.1

Two forms of protection are distinguished, hard protections being statutory immunities or defences and soft protections being non-binding frameworks that could in some cases acquire legal weight, and the response notes that the evidence base for hard protections is currently small, that no decision on statutory protection has been made and that the government will respond to the IETA recommendations in due course.1

ElementPosition in the response
DefinitionGovernment-backed protections reducing reputational, legal and other risks for organisations following defined rules
Who is developing optionsIETA, through work the government commissioned via the Coalition to Grow Carbon Markets
ScopeIntegrity of the credit and integrity of the claim
Hard protectionStatutory immunity or defence; evidence base described as small
Soft protectionNon-binding framework that could in some cases gain legal weight
DecisionNone yet; response to IETA recommendations in due course

Table 2 · Safe harbour as set out in the government response. Source: DESNZ, Defra and HM Treasury, government response, 12 November 2026, section on safe harbour.

The United Kingdom signed the Antalya Statement on Mobilising Private Finance for Climate Action at COP31 on 12 November 2026, alongside thirteen other governments, and the statement launched a Policy Playbook of eight levers that governments can use to grow corporate demand for high-integrity credits, so that the recognition scheme proposed in the response and the safe harbour work can both be read against that playbook as it is taken up by the Coalition members in 2027.3

6

Demand and Oversight

The demand measures in the response consist of practical guidance for UK organisations due in spring 2027, which will cover the steps from planning to retirement and disclosure and will replace the carbon market provisions of the Environmental Reporting Guidelines, a possible recognition scheme for organisations that follow it, procurement measures and the exploration of a Woodland Carbon Purchase Fund, and compliance-linked demand through the integration of greenhouse gas removals into the UK ETS and the implementation of CORSIA, while credit-use mandates and fiscal measures were considered and not adopted.1

The UK has legislated to include international aviation and shipping emissions in Carbon Budget 6, later budgets and the 2050 target, and it intends to count CORSIA credits bought by UK airlines for flights departing the UK, subject to conditions on integrity, with a separate response on CORSIA offsetting due later this year and legislation to follow, while carbon budgets are otherwise to be met domestically and the government reserves the right to cooperate under Article 6.1

Oversight will rest with a UK Carbon and Nature Markets Regulator Forum whose members include Defra, DESNZ, HM Treasury, the Financial Conduct Authority, the ASA, the Environment Agency, Natural England, the Forestry Commission and the devolved regulators, which will map oversight, share intelligence and recommend priorities without regulating markets, its initial phase running in the first half of 2027 before a review of its effectiveness.1

For nature markets, BSI launched Flex 702 for biodiversity and Flex 704 for nutrients in March 2026 under the Nature Investment Standards, building on the common principles of Flex 701,5 the market version of Flex 703 for nature-based carbon is expected in 2027, and the response expects a Community Engagement and Benefits Code of Practice in early 2027, BSI having released a first version of the code for public consultation as Flex 705 in March 2026, and assurance will begin with a minimum two-year period of self-assessment before moving to certification by UKAS-accredited bodies.1

Milestones set by the government response
Mar 2026
BSI Flex 702 (biodiversity) and Flex 704 (nutrients) launched under the Nature Investment Standards
12 Nov 2026
Government response published; UK signs the Antalya Statement at COP31
Late 2026
Separate government response on CORSIA offsetting, with legislation to follow
Early 2027
Community Engagement and Benefits Code of Practice, following the BSI Flex 705 consultation version of March 2026
H1 2027
Initial phase of the Carbon and Nature Markets Regulator Forum
Spring 2027
Practical guidance for UK organisations, replacing the carbon market provisions of the Environmental Reporting Guidelines
2027
Market version of Flex 703 (nature-based carbon); approach to SAF Mandate and GGR demand
2027 to 2029
Proof-of-concept project for a nature market assurance framework
Figure 2 · Milestones for UK voluntary carbon and nature markets set out in the government response. Source: DESNZ, Defra and HM Treasury, government response, 12 November 2026, next steps.
7

Outlook

The response leaves three matters for 2027, being the content of the spring guidance, the form of any recognition scheme attached to it and the government decision on the IETA safe harbour options, and a UK company buying credits now has enough in the response to set its approach in the meantime.1

  1. Credit purchases should be planned against the three endorsed uses, with ongoing emissions responsibility under SBTi V2.0 and durable removals for residual emissions kept distinct in internal records.
  2. Procurement criteria should give priority to CCP-labelled and PACM credits where supply exists, and any purchase outside that pool should be documented with the reason and the assurance relied on.
  3. Public claims should be checked against the ASA guidance of July 2026 and should describe a contribution rather than neutrality, in line with the position the European Union has taken in law.
  4. Disclosures should state whether a corresponding adjustment applies to each credit retired, since the response encourages that reporting even where the adjustment is not required.
  5. Companies seeking recognition or protection should follow the Coalition Policy Playbook and the IETA options work, since the spring guidance and any safe harbour are expected to build on them.

The response confirms the direction of UK policy without yet changing the legal position of a buyer, so that the value of following it in 2027 will depend on whether the recognition scheme and the safe harbour carry weight with the ASA, the courts and investors.1,3

Climate Decode Platform

Market Watch tracks voluntary credit supply, labels and prices, and Canopy supports buyers with credit strategy, due diligence and claims.

Market Watch • VCM
Voluntary Carbon Market

Supply, CCP labels, retirements and prices across the main registries.

Open Market Watch →
Platform • Canopy
Canopy

Residual emissions strategy, credit procurement and claims for corporate buyers.

Explore Canopy →

Canopy · Insetting and Residual Emissions

Develop an insetting or residual emissions management strategy with Canopy, with full confidence

Canopy comes with the policy landscape and peer benchmarks already built in, detailed due diligence on every credit, and reporting expertise under SBTi FLAG and the GHG Protocol Land Sector and Removals Standard.

Notes

1 Department for Energy Security and Net Zero, Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs and HM Treasury, Voluntary Carbon and Nature Markets: Raising Integrity, Government Response, 12 November 2026, sections on use cases, quality, claims, corresponding adjustments, SBTi, safe harbour, demand, nature markets, the Regulator Forum, CORSIA and next steps. link
2 DESNZ, Voluntary Carbon and Nature Markets: Raising Integrity, consultation, 17 April to 10 July 2025, and summary of responses, 26 March 2026. link
3 Coalition to Grow Carbon Markets, Countries issue joint Antalya Statement at COP31 on policy implementation to grow international carbon credit markets, 12 November 2026, and the Policy Playbook to Grow Demand for High-Integrity Carbon Credits. link
4 Committee of Advertising Practice and Broadcast Committee of Advertising Practice, Misleading environmental claims and social responsibility in advertising, updated 30 July 2026, section on carbon neutral, net zero and similar claims; CAP, Greenspeaking with Confidence: environmental claims in advertising, July 2026. link 1 link 2
5 BSI, BSI Flex 702 v2.0:2026-03, Nature markets: Supply of biodiversity benefits, Specification, March 2026, foreword, listing Flex 703 v1.0:2025-03, Flex 704 v2.0:2026-03 and Flex 705 v1.0:2026-03, the last released for public consultation. link

Sources

Purchase values are those reported in the government response for UK companies in the first half of 2026; the share of overseas purchases is calculated from the two values given. Positions are those of the response as published and may change with the spring 2027 guidance.

Market Watch • VCM, CORSIA & Article 6
Voluntary, CORSIA and Article 6 credits in one view
Supply, pricing and the 2026 outlook for voluntary, CORSIA-eligible and Article 6 credits.
Open Market Watch →

About the Author

Vaibhav Jain, Managing Director, Climate Decode

Vaibhav Jain

Managing Director, Climate Decode

12+ years in carbon markets and climate finance across four continents. Leads the Canopy product and aligned advisory services in corporate sustainability. 79+ projects delivered across 25 countries. Formerly South Pole · Yes Bank · PwC.

Speak to Vaibhav → Meet the team →

© 2026 Climate Decode · Market Analysis · Reference CD-VCM-UKGR

Series Home Insights Home Contact Us

Newsletter

Carbon market insights, to your inbox

Regulatory shifts, market outlooks and new tools from Climate Decode. Work email only — first and last name optional. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.

Subscribe to insights →