Mejuruá REDD+ in Court: Consent, Land and the Katukina
A federal court has barred BR Arbo from contacting the Katukina people while prosecutors allege that the project overlaps Indigenous and traditional territories. Climate Decode sets the case against the consent rules that buyers should test.
At a Glance · The Mejuruá Case
|
The order CONTACT BARRED On 5 November 2026 the 3rd Civil Federal Court of the Judicial Section of Amazonas barred BR Arbo from contacting the Katukina people, without suspending the project.1 |
The claim ALLEGED OVERLAP Federal prosecutors allege that more than 50% of a declared area of about 678,000 hectares overlaps traditional and Indigenous territories.2 |
The status VALIDATED, NO ISSUANCE REDD-Monitor reports a validation report dated 9 October 2026 and no credits issued on Verra’s registry.1 |
The court declined to suspend the project but barred BR Arbo from contact with a recently contacted people and named ownership of the land as the central question, so that a validated project with no issuance already carries legal risk on its underlying asset.1
Verra’s Version 5, the Integrity Council’s CCP 9 and Brazil’s Law 15.042 each point to documented consent and title, so that a buyer can ask for the same evidence under all three.4,6,9
The allegations are those of the Federal Public Prosecutor’s Office, so that Climate Decode treats the case as a signal of where due diligence is heading and not as a finding about the project.1,2
|
1
|
The Court Order and the Prosecutors’ Claim |
The Federal Public Prosecutor’s Office (MPF) announced on 29 October 2026 a public civil action against BR Arbo Gestão Florestal and Verra, seeking suspension of the Mejuruá project in Carauari, Amazonas, annulment of its registrations over community and Indigenous lands, and R$6 million in collective moral damages.2 According to REDD-Monitor, the 3rd Civil Federal Court of the Judicial Section of Amazonas ruled on 5 November 2026 that BR Arbo and anyone acting in the project’s interest must have no direct or indirect contact with the Katukina people and must not enter the Rio Biá Indigenous Land, while declining to suspend the project or restrain the sale of credits and stating that the central question is who owns the land.1
The MPF alleges that the project advanced without the consultation required by ILO Convention 169, that residents were pressured, and that Verra continued to audit the project after being notified of irregularities.2 BR Arbo is reported to say that it contacted the national Indigenous agency FUNAI in March 2023, while Verra stated on 11 November 2026 that it had not been notified of any legal proceeding, and EPIC, the validation auditor, is reported to have dismissed the claims that the project lacked free, prior and informed consent, so that each statement remains the position of a party and not a finding.1 Climate Decode did not open the decision text and follows REDD-Monitor’s account of it.
Table 1 · Mejuruá chronology. Sources: REDD-Monitor, 17 December 2025 and 13 November 2026. Based on information the company has reported publicly, and on allegations not tested at trial.
|
2
|
The Project and Its Registry Status |
The project is listed as Verra project 4485 and was submitted under the VCS and CCB standards in 2023, and the areas quoted differ by source, with REDD-Monitor giving 123,762 hectares and a potential expansion to 668,116 hectares while the MPF cites a declared area of about 678,000 hectares, of which its geoprocessing studies found more than 50% overlapping traditional and Indigenous territories, including 179,149 hectares of the Riozinho communities and 38,856 hectares of the Juruá communities, with the remainder attributed to the Katukina, for which the release gives no hectare figure, while the two named areas total 32.10% of the declared area, and REDD-Monitor’s December 2025 text also cites 130,641 hectares without explaining the difference from 123,762.1,2,3 The sources do not state how much of the overlap lies within the area currently submitted, so that the exposure of a first issuance cannot yet be sized.
REDD-Monitor reports no credits issued and a validation report dated 9 October 2026, and Climate Decode could not open the registry page, so that the status should be confirmed there.1
Climate Decode screens REDD+ credits for consent, title and benefit-sharing evidence alongside methodology and label, so that forward purchases can be compared on one basis.
Book a briefing → Subscribe to insights →|
3
|
What Consent Requires Under Verra, ART TREES and the CCPs |
Verra’s VCS Version 5, whose programme updates take effect mostly from 1 January 2027 according to Verra’s notice, replaces project ownership with a duty to substantiate the right to operate, adds a check for overlapping or competing claims, reinforces FPIC for customary rights holders and Indigenous Peoples, and requires a jointly designed benefit-sharing mechanism before the project starts, at sections 3.6 and 3.17 according to a commentary.4,5 Verra notes a longer transition period for some updates on existing projects, and our analysis reports that existing projects move to the Version 5 safeguards after 1 January 2030, so that a project submitted in 2023 may be assessed against the earlier edition, as our analysis of the Integrity Council decision sets out.13
The Integrity Council’s CCP 9 expects FPIC processes with Indigenous Peoples and local communities where the context requires, while its October 2025 report recommends more inclusive engagement but is not yet policy.6,7 ART TREES, covered in our analysis of ART architecture, rests on the seven Cancun Safeguards in 16 themes and 44 indicators reported by the jurisdiction, so that assurance sits with the jurisdiction’s system and not with a developer’s own consultation record.8
|
4
|
Brazil’s Law 15.042 on Indigenous Lands and Benefit Sharing |
Law 15.042 of 11 December 2024, in the text published by the Federal Senate, gives Indigenous communities originary title to credits from Indigenous lands under Article 231 of the Constitution and, in Article 47, conditions projects in traditionally occupied territories on consent from free, prior and informed consultation under ILO Convention 169 paid for by the developer, with communities entitled to at least 50% of the credits from removal projects and at least 70% from market-approach REDD+ projects, and the Senate text confirms both shares in Article 47, item I, letter b.9
The MPF contends that BR Arbo breached the law and Conaredd+ Resolution 19/2025, which in the MPF’s description require at least 70% of financial benefits to pass to affected populations, by not doing so, a point on which the sources reviewed report no response, so that how the law applies to a project registered under a voluntary standard remains for the court.2
|
5
|
Colombia’s Nonuya Ruling as a Pattern |
On 4 September 2026 the Constitutional Court of Colombia, in ruling T-283 of 2026, found that Oxigreen S.A.S. violated the rights of the Nonuya de Villazul Indigenous reservation by not ensuring participation in the project design document and by treating withdrawal of consent as a contract dispute, holding that FPIC includes the power to withdraw consent where circumstances change substantially.10 The Court found that the evidence did not establish that validation, certification or issuance had been completed, whereas in Brazil a validation report is reported but no issuance, so that two Amazon jurisdictions, about two months apart, have heard consent disputes before any credit existed and a forward buyer carries the risk that consent is contested or withdrawn after signature.10,11
|
6
|
What Buyers Should Check |
Table 2 sets out the checks that Climate Decode applies to REDD+ credits from Indigenous and traditional territories.
Table 2 · Due diligence checks for REDD+ credits from Indigenous and traditional territories. Sources: Verra; Law 15.042 of 2024; Constitutional Court of Colombia; Climate Decode analysis.
Because no credits have been issued, the exposure of a forward buyer lies in delivery and reputation, so that Climate Decode advises writing these conditions into purchase agreements and obtaining the evidence before payment, while the points to watch are whether the MPF pursues suspension on the merits and how Verra responds once notified.
Climate Decode Platform
Registry status for projects such as this one is tracked in Canopy Market Watch, which follows issuance, retirements, ratings and labels across ten registries.
Supply, demand and pricing across voluntary, CORSIA-eligible and Article 6 credits, by country, project type and methodology.
Open Market Watch →Canopy’s due diligence engine tests REDD+ baselines, leakage, permanence, consent and title evidence, and keeps an audit-ready record of every purchase.
Explore Canopy →Notes
2 Federal Public Prosecutor’s Office (MPF), Procuradoria da República no Amazonas, press release of 29 October 2026 (public civil action No. 1057877-05.2026.4.01.3200; areas, percentages and requests; Law 15.042 and Conaredd+ Resolution 19/2025 allegations).
3 REDD-Monitor, “Statement opposing the Mejuruá REDD project in the State of Amazonas, Brazil”, 17 December 2025 (project 4485; chronology of 2025; 123,762 and 668,116 hectares).
4 Verra, VCS Version 5 launch page and programme notice (right to operate; FPIC; benefit-sharing mechanism; effective date of 1 January 2027).
5 Sustainable Development Strategy Group, “Verra’s Carbon Standard 5.0: Integrity Through Rights and Benefit-Sharing?”, 9 February 2026 (commentary on sections 3.6 and 3.17).
6 Integrity Council for the Voluntary Carbon Market, Core Carbon Principles, Section 3, version 2, 6 February 2024 (CCP 9).
7 Integrity Council for the Voluntary Carbon Market, report on stronger safeguards approaches, 29 October 2025.
8 UN-REDD Programme, training on safeguards requirements under the ART TREES standard (Cancun Safeguards, 16 themes, 44 indicators).
9 Brazil, Law No. 15.042 of 11 December 2024, Articles 4, 28, 43, 47 and 48; Federal Senate publication of the original text (legis.senado.leg.br, norma 39923461), read 16 November 2026; Article 47, I, b sets at least 50% of credits from removal projects and at least 70% from market-approach REDD+ projects for Indigenous peoples and traditional communities.
10 Constitutional Court of Colombia, ruling T-283 of 2026, Sixth Review Chamber, 4 September 2026.
11 The Rio Times, report on Colombian Constitutional Court ruling T-283 and the Nonuya de Villazul reservation, 2026 (Court finding on validation and issuance; agreement of 20 September 2021).
12 InfoCarbono, Camargo e Gomes Advogados, edition 13, on Verra’s denial of registration published on 9 April 2025 (a newsletter that takes a position in favour of the communities).
13 Climate Decode, ICVCM Makes Verra VCS v5 CCP-Eligible (transition of existing projects to Version 5 safeguard requirements after 1 January 2030).
Sources
Federal Public Prosecutor’s Office (MPF): action against BR Arbo and Verra, 29 October 2026
REDD-Monitor: Statement opposing the Mejuruá REDD project, 17 December 2025
Verra: Verra launches Version 5 of the VCS Program
Sustainable Development Strategy Group: Verra’s Carbon Standard 5.0, 9 February 2026
ICVCM: Core Carbon Principles, Section 3, version 2, 6 February 2024
ICVCM: New report highlights stronger safeguards approaches, 29 October 2025
UN-REDD: Safeguards requirements under the ART TREES standard
Brazil: Lei nº 15.042, de 11 de dezembro de 2024
Constitutional Court of Colombia: Sentencia T-283 de 2026
The Rio Times: Colombia court, Nonuya and carbon credits, 2026
InfoCarbono, edition 13: Verra cede à pressão de comunidades no Amazonas
Climate Decode: ICVCM Makes Verra VCS v5 CCP-Eligible
The allegations described are those of the Federal Public Prosecutor’s Office and have not been tested at trial. The court decision text and the Verra registry page were not opened by Climate Decode, and the account of both follows REDD-Monitor; details may change as the proceeding develops.
|
© 2026 Climate Decode · Market Analysis · Reference CD-VCM-FPIC-01 |
Series Home Insights Home Contact Us |