CBAM Carbon Price Deduction by Market: Net Effective Price in Canada, WCI and India
Regulation (EU) 2026/2498 sets how a carbon price paid outside the EU reduces CBAM certificates, and the amount depends on the share of emissions that an installation actually pays for and on the price it paid, which in Alberta has been CAD 36 for credits against a CAD 95 fund price in Climate Decode Market Watch.
At a Glance · The CBAM Deduction by Market
|
Observed price THE PRICE ACTUALLY PAID Alberta TIER credits averaged CAD 36 in 2026 against the CAD 95 fund price, and Ontario units CAD 70.08 against the CAD 80 charge.818 |
Paying share WHAT ACTUALLY PAYS Output-based standards and free allocation leave installations paying on about 5% to 15% of emissions.71213 |
CBAM effect THE DEDUCTION At EUR 82.32 an Alberta facility paying on 11% avoids about 3.0% of gross certificates at CAD 36 and 7.9% at CAD 95, being about 9% and 24% of the 2026 obligation net of the free allocation adjustment for hot-rolled steel.51820 |
Regulation (EU) 2026/2498 allows an EU importer to reduce the CBAM certificates it surrenders by the carbon price that the producing installation has effectively paid abroad, and it measures that price as the emissions on which the installation actually paid, multiplied by the price per tonne it paid, converted into euro and divided by the CBAM certificate price. Free allowances, emissions below a baseline, exemptions and refunds are treated as rebates and subtracted before the price is applied, so that the deduction follows the money that left the installation rather than the headline price of the system in which it operates.3419
The same rule applies to every system listed in Annex II, but it gives different results according to how each system charges. A carbon tax charges the installation on the emissions it covers, less any reduced rate or exemption; the output-based systems in Canada and India’s CCTS charge only on emissions above the installation’s intensity benchmark; and cap-and-trade in Quebec and California charges only for the allowances bought beyond the free allocation, so that under the last two designs an installation typically pays on between 5% and 15% of its emissions.271213
An installation that beats its benchmark under an output-based system, or whose free allocation covers all of its emissions under cap-and-trade, has paid nothing and so receives no deduction, and the credits it earns or the surplus allowances it sells are not counted, since the Regulation contains no provision under which the effective price can fall below zero. Such an installation is nonetheless the cheaper one to import from, because CBAM charges on actual embedded emissions, and Table 1 shows a hypothetical hot-rolled steel plant exporting 10,000 tonnes in 2026, worked through in full in section 4, after the free allocation adjustment of 13,358 certificates.1920
| Installation | Embedded emissions, tCO2e per tonne | Carbon price paid at home | Deduction, certificates | Certificates to surrender | Cost at EUR 82.32 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| TIER plant above its benchmark of 1.75 | 1.90 | On 0.15 t per tonne, at a mix of the CAD 95 fund price and CAD 36 credits | 813 | 4,829 | EUR 397,523 |
| TIER plant below its benchmark | 1.70 | Nothing; earns credits it can sell | 0 | 3,642 | EUR 299,809 |
| Cap-and-trade plant whose free allocation covers all its emissions | 1.70 | Nothing; may sell surplus allowances | 0 | 3,642 | EUR 299,809 |
Table 1 · The same steel product from three installations, 2026, at CAD 1.60 per EUR. The cleaner plants surrender 1,187 fewer certificates, about EUR 97,700 less, without any deduction.
The price counted for credits and offsets is the price the installation paid for them, at no more than the system’s main compliance price, and credits it did not buy are priced at zero unless a market price is evidenced, so that the effect on the deduction depends on how much of the obligation each system allows credits to cover. Alberta’s TIER allows emission performance credits, offsets and sequestration credits to meet up to 90% of a facility’s obligation from 2026, and Climate Decode’s pricing model puts TIER credits at an average of CAD 36 in 2026 against the CAD 95 fund price, so that a facility settling its shortfall mostly with credits carries a weighted price much closer to CAD 36 than to CAD 95.161822
British Columbia, by contrast, limits earned credits and offsets to 30% of a facility’s compensation from 2026 to 2030, so that at least 70% is paid at the compliance charge and the weighted price stays close to it.23 Quebec and California cap offsets at 8% and 6% of the compliance obligation respectively, with Quebec moving to 6% from 2027, and since that obligation covers all emissions the cap is small against the total but can be a large part of the allowances an installation actually buys when free allocation covers most of its emissions. The 10% limit in the Regulation applies only to credits transferred under Article 6 of the Paris Agreement and does not touch any of these domestic units.1624
India’s CCTS sets intensity targets, notified in October 2025 for sectors that include aluminium and cement, under which an installation above its target buys Carbon Credit Certificates for the shortfall and an installation below it is issued certificates, so that only the first can claim a deduction, at the price it paid. No certificate has yet traded, the floor and forbearance prices have not been notified and the first compliance year runs from April 2025 to March 2026, so that a 2026 import is unlikely to carry an evidenced price by the time the first CBAM declarations are due in September 2027, and the deduction for Indian goods should be planned at nil.1415
The CBAM cost of Indian goods in 2026 therefore turns on embedded emissions rather than on the CCTS, and verified actual emissions are the larger lever, since default values carry a mark-up of 10% in 2026 that rises in later years. An Indian installation that beats its CCTS target gains twice, once through the certificates it can sell at home and once through the smaller number of CBAM certificates its EU customer surrenders, which is the same outcome as for the cleaner plants in Table 1.1525
|
1
|
What the Regulation Sets |
Commission Implementing Regulation (EU) 2026/2498, adopted on 5 November 2026 and published on 16 November 2026, applies from 1 January 2026 and so governs the 2026 imports in the first CBAM declarations, due by 30 September 2027.12 Its Annex II names the federal OBPS, Alberta’s TIER, British Columbia’s OBPS, Ontario’s Emissions Performance Standards, the Quebec and California cap-and-trade systems and India’s Carbon Credit Trading Scheme, although the list is non-exhaustive and absence from it does not make a scheme ineligible.12
Under Articles 6 and 7 the price effectively paid per tonne of good is converted into euro at the Commission’s yearly average rate, divided by the yearly reference certificate price and multiplied by the quantity declared.3 The Commission has published EUR 75.36, EUR 75.28 and EUR 82.32 for the first three quarters of 2026, which average EUR 77.65 until the fourth-quarter price is published, so that every share below rises by about 6% if the yearly average applies instead of the EUR 82.32 used for illustration.5 This extends our pages on the Canadian deduction, whose illustration assumes a federal OBPS benchmark covering 80% of emissions and so a 20% paying share, a higher starting point than the 5% to 10% read for a facility at its sector average here, and on the CCTS and CBAM.
|
2
|
Net Effective Price by Market |
Table 2 sets the headline fund or compliance price of each market beside the price that Climate Decode Market Watch has observed for the credits or units used to settle a shortfall, multiplies each price by the share of emissions the installation pays for, and divides the converted result by the EUR 82.32 Q3 2026 certificate price, at assumed rates of CAD 1.60 and USD 1.16 to the euro that are illustrations and not the Commission’s yearly averages, whereas the Commission’s yearly average of the quarterly certificate prices applies in practice.51718 The last column restates the result against the 2026 obligation net of the free allocation adjustment, for an illustrative hot-rolled steel product carrying 1.90 tonnes of embedded emissions per tonne against a CBAM benchmark of 1.370 for the blast furnace route at the 97.5% CBAM factor, under which 29.7% of the gross obligation remains due before any deduction.20
| Market | Headline fund or compliance price, 2026 | Market Watch observed price (instrument, period) | Paying share of emissions | Net effective price per tonne of embedded emissions | CBAM certificates avoided | Share of 2026 net obligation, steel illustration |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Federal OBPS | CAD 956 | No observed series in Market Watch | 5% to 10%7 | Observed not available Fund CAD 4.75 to 9.50 | Observed not available Fund 3.6% to 7.2% | Observed not available Fund 12.1% to 24.3% |
| Alberta TIER | CAD 95 fund price8 | CAD 36.00 average of emission performance credit prints, calendar 2026 to October (CAD 25.00 in 2025)18 | 5% to 15%7 | Observed CAD 1.80 to 5.40 Fund CAD 4.75 to 14.25 | Observed 1.4% to 4.1% Fund 3.6% to 10.8% | Observed 4.6% to 13.8% Fund 12.1% to 36.4% |
| British Columbia OBPS | CAD 80 compliance price, 2024 period9 | About CAD 65, one print for earned credits and offsets, 2024 compliance period18 | 5% to 35%9 | Observed CAD 3.25 to 22.75 Fund CAD 4.00 to 28.00 | Observed 2.5% to 17.3% Fund 3.0% to 21.3% | Observed 8.3% to 58.2% Fund 10.2% to 71.6% |
| Ontario EPS | CAD 80 emissions excess charge10 | CAD 70.08 average transfer price of emission performance units, compliance period 2024, 12.4% below the charge18 | Facility specific10 | Not computed | Not computed | Not computed |
| Quebec | USD 32.48 joint auction settlement, 19 August 202611 | Auction results forthcoming in Market Watch; 2026 floor CAD 26.4718 | 5% to 15%12 | Observed not available Settlement USD 1.62 to 4.87 | Observed not available Settlement 1.7% to 5.1% | Observed not available Settlement 5.7% to 17.2% |
| California | USD 32.48 joint auction settlement, 19 August 202611 | Auction results forthcoming in Market Watch; 2026 floor USD 27.9418 | 0% to 10%13 | Observed not available Settlement USD 0 to 3.25 | Observed not available Settlement 0% to 3.4% | Observed not available Settlement 0% to 11.5% |
| India CCTS | Floor and forbearance band not yet notified14 | Carbon Credit Certificate price modelled under Market Watch; no trade observed | Shortfall only15 | Not computable | Not computable | Not computable |
Table 2 · Headline fund or compliance price, Market Watch observed price, paying share, net effective price and CBAM certificates avoided by market. Shares are illustrative ranges, not forecasts; net prices and certificates are shown at the observed price and at the fund price (at the settlement price for Quebec and California), at CAD 1.60 and USD 1.16 per EUR and EUR 82.32 per certificate, where the Commission’s yearly average applies in practice. The last column divides the certificates avoided by the 2026 net obligation of 29.7% of gross for hot-rolled steel at 1.90 tCO2e per tonne, a CBAM benchmark of 1.370 and a CBAM factor of 97.5%, and Quebec is converted at the USD rate for illustration, although a Quebec operator’s local currency is the Canadian dollar and the Commission’s CAD rate would apply.
Source: Climate Decode Market Watch, Alberta TIER prints to October 2026, BC OBPS 2024 compliance period, Ontario EPS compliance period 2024; CARB and Quebec joint auction, 19 August 2026.18
Because the deduction rests on the carbon price effectively paid, an installation in an output-based system covers its shortfall either by paying the fund or compliance price (CAD 95 into the Alberta TIER fund in 2026, CAD 80 in British Columbia and CAD 80 as the Ontario emissions excess charge) or by buying credits or units at the market price, and Market Watch has logged Alberta TIER emission performance credits at an average of CAD 36.00 in calendar 2026, a British Columbia print of about CAD 65 for the 2024 compliance period and an Ontario average transfer price of CAD 70.08 in compliance period 2024, when about one sixth of the Ontario obligation was met with emission performance units.318 The headline benchmark price therefore overstates the deduction twice over, first because only the shortfall share pays and second because that shortfall is usually settled with credits below the fund price, so that the Market Watch credit price is the number an exporter should put in front of its EU customer and the fund price applies only where the installation actually paid it.318 Where an installation settles part of its shortfall at the fund price and part with credits, Annex I to the Regulation takes the average of the two weighted by the emissions each covers, so that the observed and fund figures in Table 2 bound the result rather than describe two separate cases.19 Under Article 9 the certifier will want the transaction evidence for the credits, which the prints logged in Market Watch help to benchmark without replacing the contract, registry transfer or invoice that evidences each purchase.418
The Government of Canada’s federal benchmark page lists CAD 95 for 2026, CAD 100 for 2027 to 2029, CAD 115 for 2030 and CAD 130 for 2035 as the headline price of all industrial systems from 15 May 2026, as reported by ICAP, whereas the February 2026 IISD review still showed CAD 110 under the schedule it replaced.67 Federal standards for trade-exposed sectors began at 90% or 95% of base intensity, so that a facility at the sector average pays on 5% to 10% before tightening, while Alberta’s TIER, priced at CAD 95 under the agreement between the Government of Canada and the Government of Alberta, began at 95% of baseline and has tightened by 2% a year since 2023, so that the 11% used here is Climate Decode’s assumption for a facility at its own baseline intensity within the 5% to 15% range.78
The Government of British Columbia applies a reduction factor of 65% for most products and up to 95% for aluminium smelting, which the Government of British Columbia’s guidance multiplies by the average intensity to set the emissions limit, so that it is the free share and the paying share is its complement, and Ontario sets standards facility by facility, so that its paying share is not computed and Table 2 shows only the CAD 80 charge against the observed CAD 70.08.91018 The joint auction settled at USD 32.48 on 19 August 2026, with the 2026 floors at CAD 26.47 in Quebec and USD 27.94 in California while Market Watch auction results are forthcoming, Quebec’s free allocation falls through a formula whose 5% to 15% outcome is assumed, and California holds industrial assistance factors at 100% through 2030, so that its range reflects only emissions above benchmark.11121318
TerraNova computes the CBAM certificates a producer’s exports carry, applies the net carbon price deduction under Regulation 2026/2498 market by market, and shows where the exposure can be reduced through product mix, verified actual emissions against defaults, and the evidence for the deduction.
Compute your CBAM exposure → Subscribe to insights →|
3
|
A Worked Example for an Exporter |
For an assumed shipment of 1,000 tonnes carrying 2.0 tonnes of embedded emissions per tonne, an intensity assumed because no published sector benchmark was found, an Alberta facility paying on 11% of its emissions settles its shortfall at the Market Watch observed credit price of CAD 36 at a cost of 2,000 × 36 × 0.11, or CAD 7,920, which is EUR 4,950 at CAD 1.60 and, divided by EUR 82.32, avoids about 60 of 2,000 certificates, a share of 3.0%, whereas the same shortfall settled at the CAD 95 fund price costs 2,000 × 95 × 0.11, or CAD 20,900, which is EUR 13,063 and avoids about 159 certificates, a share of 7.9%, so that the fund price would overstate the deduction by about 99 certificates if the credits were bought at the observed price.381718 If the shipment were hot-rolled steel, the free allocation adjustment of 1.336 tonnes per tonne on 1,000 tonnes would remove 1,336 certificates and leave about 664 due in 2026 before the deduction, against which the 60 certificates avoided at CAD 36 are 9.1% and the 159 avoided at CAD 95 are 23.9%.20 A Californian facility whose emissions are fully covered by its free allocation under a 100% assistance factor pays nothing and earns no deduction, so that its importer surrenders certificates for the whole obligation net of the free allocation adjustment, being about 664 of the 2,000 for the same steel shipment.1320
At the yearly average of EUR 77.65 the Alberta result rises to about 64 certificates at CAD 36 and to about 168 at CAD 95, and Climate Decode has modelled these outcomes under Market Watch, where the direction is that the deduction stays a small fraction of the obligation wherever standards or free allocation cover most emissions.5
|
4
|
Steel Plant Example |
A hypothetical hot-rolled flat steel plant (CN 7208) priced under Alberta’s TIER exports 10,000 tonnes to the EU in 2026 with actual direct embedded emissions of 1.90 tCO2e per tonne against a facility benchmark of 1.75, and settles 60% of its shortfall at the CAD 95 fund price and 40% with emission performance credits bought at the Market Watch average of CAD 36, at the CAD 1.60 rate and the EUR 82.32 certificate price used above.81718 Only direct emissions count for iron and steel under Regulation (EU) 2023/956, so that the indirect term of the aggregation is zero, and the precursors are assumed to be produced within the same installation, so that Table 3 carries the calculation from the price paid in Alberta to the certificates surrendered in the EU.1920
| Step | Rule | Calculation | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| Weighted price of the compliance options | Annex I, equation 4a | 0.60 × 95 + 0.40 × 36 | CAD 71.40 per tCO2e |
| Effective price after refunds | Annex I, equation 6a | 71.40 − 0, no refund assumed | CAD 71.40 per tCO2e |
| Price per tonne of steel, net of emissions below the benchmark | Annex I, equation 12a | (1.90 − 1.75) × 71.40 | CAD 10.71 per tonne |
| Conversion to euro | Annex I, equations 15a and 16 | 10.71 ÷ 1.60 | EUR 6.69 per tonne |
| Reduction for the carbon price paid | Article 7(1) | (6.69 ÷ 82.32) × 10,000 | 813 certificates |
| Gross embedded emissions | Regulation (EU) 2023/956 | 1.90 × 10,000 | 19,000 certificates |
| Free allocation adjustment | Implementing Regulation (EU) 2025/2620 | 1.370 × 0.975 × 1.0 × 10,000 | 13,358 certificates |
| Certificates to surrender | Gross less adjustment less reduction | 19,000 − 13,358 − 813 | 4,829 certificates |
| Cost at the Q3 2026 certificate price | 4,829 × EUR 82.32 | EUR 397,523 |
Table 3 · From the carbon price paid to the certificates surrendered, hypothetical TIER steel plant, 2026. CAD 1.60 per EUR and EUR 82.32 per certificate are illustrations; the Commission’s yearly average rate and yearly reference price apply to the reduction in practice, and certificates are bought at the quarterly price.
The reduction of 813 certificates is 4.3% of the gross obligation of 19,000 but 14.4% of the 5,643 certificates due after the free allocation adjustment, and the same shortfall would have reduced the obligation by 1,082 certificates had it been settled entirely at the fund price, against 410 had it been met entirely with credits at CAD 36.1920 Without any deduction the importer would surrender 5,643 certificates at a cost of about EUR 464,500, so that the carbon price paid in Alberta saves the importer about EUR 67,000 on this shipment.
The same plant at 1.70 tCO2e per tonne, below its benchmark of 1.75, pays nothing under TIER and generates credits, and since all of its emissions are then rebated under Annex I the effective price per tonne of steel is zero and the deduction is nil, so that its importer surrenders 17,000 less 13,358, or 3,642 certificates at EUR 299,809, being 1,187 fewer than for the plant above, with the whole difference arising from lower embedded emissions and none from the carbon price.19 The Regulation does not count the value of credits generated or sold and contains no provision under which the effective carbon price can fall below zero, so that an installation that outperforms its benchmark should plan its CBAM costs on the basis that no deduction will be available.219
The CBAM benchmark of 1.370 is the value in the Annex to Implementing Regulation (EU) 2025/2620 for hot-rolled flat products made on the blast furnace and basic oxygen furnace route (0.481 on the DRI and EAF route and 0.072 on the scrap and EAF route), and the Regulation bases the 2026 to 2030 benchmarks on the EU ETS benchmarks for that period with a review once the final values are published, while an operator declaring actual emissions would use the benchmarks for its own production route and the cross-sectoral correction factor, assumed here to be 1.0, so that the free allocation adjustment should be confirmed against the Annex to that Regulation before it is relied on.20
|
5
|
What Article 9 Nets Off |
Article 9 of the Implementing Regulation requires reduced rates, free allowances, emissions below a baseline and refunds to be netted off the price paid, and no deduction is allowed where a rebate cannot be substantiated, so that Table 4 shows what falls on each side in each market.4
| Market | Netted off as a rebate | Priced with care |
|---|---|---|
| Federal, Ontario, British Columbia | Emissions below the standard | Credits and excess emissions charges; proceeds returned to industry, such as through the federal OBPS Proceeds Fund, tested against the six conditions of Article 9(3)416 |
| Alberta TIER | Emissions below the benchmark | Fund payments at CAD 95, credits at no more than that; TIER fund grants to emitters, tested against the six conditions of Article 9(3)4816 |
| Quebec | Free allocation | Returned consignment proceeds, tested against six conditions412 |
| California | Free allocation | Allowances bought above the allocation413 |
| India CCTS | Intensity below target | Certificates bought for a shortfall415 |
Table 4 · What Article 9 nets off, by market. Sources: Regulation (EU) 2026/2498, Article 9; footnotes as shown.
Credits count within the scheme’s limits at no more than its other compliance options, and credits not bought are valued at zero unless a price is evidenced, while only credits authorised and issued under Article 6 of the Paris Agreement count and are capped at 10% of covered emissions, so that the cap touches Article 6 units and not domestic credits.116 Proceeds that a Canadian system returns to industry through decarbonisation funds count as compensation under Article 9 unless they meet all six conditions of Article 9(3), among them that every covered installation is eligible and that funding decisions are published, so that the funding rules of each programme should be documented alongside the payment records.4
|
6
|
Practical Points for Exporters and Importers |
The evidence is prepared in English on the Commission template and certified by an independent person, who for 2026 and 2027 may be an accredited CBAM verifier, whereas from 2028 specific accreditation is required, and records are kept to the end of the fourth year after the declaration year.116 The default carbon price is a second route and not only a fallback, since recital 5 says that a declarant whose embedded emissions are determined on actual values may claim the price effectively paid on certified evidence or may instead choose the relevant default carbon price, Article 7(2) gives the formula for that choice for each part of the emissions, and Article 5 adds that the default may be used for precursors produced outside the installation and for the indirect emissions of goods outside Annex II to Regulation (EU) 2023/956, while a declarant on default emission values may claim only the default carbon price, so that the exporter’s choice is between the evidence it can assemble and the default the Commission will publish for its country.21 A claim well above the default is expected to attract scrutiny under recital 9, as RegReportingDesk reads it, so that exporters should assemble standards, allocation documents and payment records before the review due by the end of 2027.116
|
7
|
The India Compliance Period Question |
India’s first compliance year is 2025 to 2026, with targets notified on 8 October 2025 for aluminium, cement, chlor-alkali, and pulp and paper against a 2023 to 2024 baseline, and the Central Electricity Regulatory Commission has provided for floor and forbearance prices that are not yet notified, while Climate Decode has modelled the Carbon Credit Certificate price under Market Watch with the direction that trading in the first compliance period is expected to clear well below the EU certificate price.141518 Only a facility above its target buys Carbon Credit Certificates, so that the paying share is the shortfall alone, and a 2026 import can deduct only the certificate price evidenced for the period to which its emissions are attributed, so that until certificates have been bought and surrendered no evidenced price exists, and the deduction for Indian goods in the first declaration will rest on the default carbon price the Commission publishes for India, which the Commission has said it will set for every country with a national carbon pricing mechanism before the first declarations are due.1521
Climate Decode Platform
The prices and rules in this analysis are tracked in Market Watch, and the exposure they create is computed in TerraNova.
TerraNova computes the CBAM certificates a producer’s exports carry, applies the net carbon price deduction under Regulation 2026/2498 market by market, and shows where the exposure can be reduced through product mix, verified actual emissions against defaults, and the evidence for the deduction.
Explore TerraNova →Canopy supports the residual-emissions side, tracking the authorisations and registry records behind the credits that a scheme accepts as a compliance option.
Explore Canopy →Notes
2 Commission Implementing Regulation (EU) 2026/2498, Official Journal, 16 November 2026, Article 4 and Annex II (text read through the EUR-Lex PDF rendering).
3 Regulation (EU) 2026/2498, Articles 6 and 7 (conversion into euro, reduction of certificates, reference price).
4 Regulation (EU) 2026/2498, Article 9 (rebates and other compensation, subsidies funded by carbon price revenues, unsubstantiated rebates). Regulation (EU) 2023/956, Article 9, was opened on EUR-Lex: it allows a reduction where the carbon price has been effectively paid in the country of origin, requires rebates to be taken into account, certification by an independent person and retention of records to the end of the fourth year after the declaration year, and empowers the Commission to adopt the implementing rules.
5 European Commission, CBAM certificate price page: Q1 2026 EUR 75.36 (published 7 April), Q2 EUR 75.28 (6 July), Q3 EUR 82.32 (5 October); Q4 scheduled for 4 January 2027. The EUR 77.65 average is Climate Decode’s arithmetic on the three published prices.
6 ICAP, “Canada publishes new carbon price trajectory”, 27 May 2026, reporting the Government of Canada’s trajectory published 19 May 2026, effective 15 May 2026: CAD 95 for 2026 and CAD 100 for 2027. The Government of Canada page, “The federal carbon pollution pricing benchmark”, was opened and lists CAD 95 for 2026, CAD 100 for 2027 to 2029, CAD 115 for 2030 and CAD 130 for 2035 as of 15 May 2026.
7 IISD, Canadian Carbon Pricing Systems Review, February 2026 (hosted by Pembina Institute): federal OBPS benchmarks at 80% of base intensity (90% or 95% for trade-exposed sectors), tightening of 1% to 2% a year; TIER benchmarks starting at 95% of baseline with 2% tightening from 2023. The 5% to 15% ranges and the 11% Alberta figure are Climate Decode’s reading; IISD records TIER tightening of 1% a year in 2020 to 2022, 2% a year from 2023 and a pause in product benchmark tightening past 2025.
8 EY Global Tax News, 3 June 2026, and Osler, on the Canada-Alberta implementation agreement: TIER price CAD 95 for 2026 and CAD 100 for 2027 to 2029.
9 ICAP, British Columbia Output-Based Pricing System, system page: reduction factor of 65% for most products, 80% to 90% for several sectors and 95% for aluminium smelting, tightening of 1% a year; price shown as CAD 110 under the earlier schedule. Table 2 pairs the observed print with the CAD 80 compliance price of the 2024 compliance period (note 18). Direction confirmed against the Government of British Columbia OBPS guidance, in which the emissions limit equals production multiplied by the reduction factor and the average intensity.
10 ICAP, Ontario Emissions Performance Standards, system page: facility-specific, sectoral or historical benchmarks, no stringency value; price shown as CAD 110 under the earlier schedule. The CAD 80 emissions excess charge is the 2024 compliance period charge stated in note 18. Not confirmed against O. Reg. 241/19.
11 California Air Resources Board, Joint Auction #48 summary results report, 19 August 2026: current auction settlement price USD 32.48 per allowance.
12 ICAP, Canada and Quebec Cap-and-Trade System, system page: free allocation decline formula from 2024. The 2026 allocation file of the Government of Quebec (18 September 2026) was not opened.
13 ICAP, California Cap-and-Invest Program, system page: industrial assistance factors at 100% through 2030 under AB 398.
14 Central Electricity Regulatory Commission, Carbon Credit Certificates trading regulations, 2026, notified 27 February 2026 and published in the Gazette of India on 27 April 2026, as summarised by IndiaLaw; no floor or forbearance values found.
15 Down To Earth, India notifies GHG emission intensity targets for four sectors, October 2025 (notification of 8 October 2025; baseline 2023 to 2024; target years 2025 to 2026 and 2026 to 2027).
16 RegReportingDesk, “CBAM carbon price deduction for third countries”, a secondary reading of Regulation (EU) 2026/2498 (certification, materiality, retention to the end of the fourth year, recital 9, credits and the 10% cap); article numbers not checked against the Official Journal text.
17 Climate Decode assumption: EUR 1 = CAD 1.60 and EUR 1 = USD 1.16, chosen for illustration; the Commission’s yearly average rates under Article 6 will apply in practice.
18 Climate Decode Market Watch (https://climate-decode.com/market-watch). Alberta TIER emission performance credit prices are annual averages of the dated Platts, broker and analyst prints logged by Climate Decode, CAD 36.00 for calendar 2026 from January to October (including trades at CAD 41 to 42 before the 15 May 2026 implementation agreement) and CAD 25.00 for 2025, with the Alberta Environment and Protected Areas annual TIER compliance summaries for 2020 to 2025 as actuals, for a page built on 22 October 2026. The British Columbia figure is the one observed print of about CAD 65 for earned credits and offsets in the 2024 compliance period, 1 April to 31 December 2024, retired in March 2026 and settled in the B.C. Carbon Registry, against the CAD 80 compliance price, for a page built on 9 October 2026. The Ontario figure is the average transfer price of CAD 70.08 per emission performance unit in compliance period 2024 against the CAD 80 emissions excess charge, with about one sixth of the 2024 obligation (799,095 units against 4,831,975 tonnes) met with units, from the Ontario Emissions Performance Standards Compliance Report 2022 to 2024, for a page dated 8 September 2026. The 2026 auction floors of CAD 26.47 (Quebec) and USD 27.94 (California) are Climate Decode reference values pending confirmation against the auction notices, and Market Watch auction results for both systems are forthcoming. No modelled or forecast value is used in the tables or the worked examples.
19 Regulation (EU) 2026/2498, Annex I, equations 1, 4a, 6a, 12a, 15a and 16, and Article 7(1), read through the EUR-Lex PDF rendering: the effective carbon price per tonne of good is (attributed emissions less rebated emissions) multiplied by the effective price per tonne, converted at the yearly average rate and summed over direct, indirect and precursor emissions; the reduction is that price divided by the yearly reference certificate price and multiplied by the quantity declared. Under Annex I, section 5(b), emissions below an emission intensity baseline under a baseline-and-credit system are rebated emissions. Only direct emissions are counted for iron and steel under Regulation (EU) 2023/956.
20 Commission Implementing Regulation (EU) 2025/2620 of 16 December 2025 on the calculation of the free allocation adjustment (Article 31 of Regulation (EU) 2023/956), Equation 1 (the specific embedded free allocation multiplied by the mass imported, with the CBAM factor and the cross-sectoral correction factor entering the specific embedded free allocation) and Annex, CN 7208: CBAM benchmark 1.370 tCO2e per tonne for carbon steel on the blast furnace and basic oxygen furnace route, 0.481 for the DRI and EAF route and 0.072 for the scrap and EAF route; recitals 9 and 10 base the 2026 to 2030 benchmarks on the EU ETS benchmarks for that period, with a review once the final ETS benchmarks are published and updated values applying to goods imported from 1 January 2027. The CBAM factor of 97.5% for 2026 is set in Article 10a(1a) of Directive 2003/87/EC.
21 Regulation (EU) 2026/2498, Article 5(1) and 5(2) and recital 5 (default carbon price for precursors produced outside the installation, for indirect emissions of goods not listed in Annex II to Regulation (EU) 2023/956, and where default emission values are used).
22 Government of Alberta, TIER compliance workshop (2024 compliance period), and Blakes, “TIER amendments provide price certainty”: maximum credit usage of 70% in 2024, 80% in 2025 and 90% in 2026 and later years, covering emission offsets, emission performance credits and sequestration credits.
23 ICAP, British Columbia Output-Based Pricing System, system page: compliance units (earned credits and offset units) may meet at most 40% of compensation in 2025 and 30% from 2026 to 2030.
24 IETA, California ETS business brief, September 2025: offset usage limit of 6% of the compliance obligation for 2026 to 2030. ICAP, “Québec updates its cap-and-trade regulation”, August 2026: the offset limit of 8% falls to 6% from the compliance period beginning in 2027.
25 Commission Implementing Regulation (EU) 2025/2621 of 16 December 2025 on default values, Annex I: mark-up on default values for iron and steel, aluminium, hydrogen and cement of 10% in 2026, 20% in 2027 and 30% from 2028, and 1% for fertilisers (recitals 4 to 6).
Sources
EUR-Lex: Commission Implementing Regulation (EU) 2026/2498, Official Journal, 16 November 2026
European Commission: Price of CBAM certificates, 2026 quarterly prices
Government of Canada: The federal carbon pollution pricing benchmark
EUR-Lex: Regulation (EU) 2023/956, Article 9
Government of British Columbia: OBPS guidance
ICAP: Canada publishes new carbon price trajectory, 27 May 2026
IISD: Canadian Carbon Pricing Systems Review, February 2026
EY: Canada and Alberta revise industrial carbon prices, 3 June 2026
Osler: Future of Canada’s carbon markets, Canada-Alberta MOU implementation agreement
ICAP: British Columbia Output-Based Pricing System
ICAP: Ontario Emissions Performance Standards
California Air Resources Board: Joint Auction #48 summary results report, 19 August 2026
ICAP: Canada and Quebec Cap-and-Trade System
ICAP: California Cap-and-Invest Program
IndiaLaw: CERC Carbon Credit Certificates regulations, 2026
Down To Earth: India notifies GHG emission intensity targets for four sectors, October 2025
Climate Decode: Market Watch
RegReportingDesk: CBAM carbon price deduction for third countries (secondary source)
Government of Alberta: TIER compliance workshop, 2024 compliance period
Blakes: TIER amendments provide price certainty
IETA: California ETS business brief, September 2025
ICAP: Québec updates its cap-and-trade regulation, August 2026
Paying shares are illustrative ranges derived from published standards and allocation rules, not installation-specific values or forecasts, and exchange rates are assumptions; observed prices are logged prints and published settlements, not forecasts. The Regulation text was read through a rendering of the Official Journal PDF.
|
© 2026 Climate Decode · Market Analysis · Reference CD-CBAM-NEP-01 |
Series Home Insights Home Contact Us |